Epidemiology of Diabetes and its Vascular Lesions, Elsevier, 1978 WHO Expert Panel on Diabetes 1979. Kelly West, MD (1925-1980) …
UNDERSTANDING THE RISING TIDE OF DIABETIC CVD
THE STRONG HEART STUDY
Barbara V Howard, PhD MedStar Research Institute
Kelly West, MD 1925-1980
George Lynn Cross Research Professor of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center Epidemiology of Diabetes and its Vascular Lesions, Elsevier, 1978 Chair, Board of Regents, National Library of Medicine Chair, IDF International Epidemiology Group WHO Expert Panel on Diabetes 1979
Kelly West, MD 1925-1980
1972 - Initiated the Lawton Area Indian Project to study and control diabetes in American Indians Diabetes in American Indians and Other Native Populations in the New World Diabetes, October, 1974 Late 70s - congressional appropriation for diabetes treatment programs for American Indians
The Strong Heart Study
A study of cardiovascular disease in American Indians, supported by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute and the Indian Health Service
Outline
The Strong Heart Study The epidemic of CVD in diabetes Risk factors - conventional and new
Variations in CHD in American Indians by IHS Area - 1975
Rate/100,000
500 400 300 200 100 0
DAK ALA ALB BEM BIL NAS NAV OK PHX POR TUC
USA
ICD-9 Codes 390448
Hospital Admissions
Phoenix PHS Indian Hospital, 1957-1966
Myocardial infarction n 61 No 28 7 1 5 7 13 61 459 115 16 82 115 213 1000 All hospital admissions N 24,121 362 220 105 84 65 164 1000
Tribe Pima Apache Navajo Papago Hopi Other SW Indians Total
Sievers, Ann Intern Med 1967;67:800
Strong Heart Study Objectives
Measure rates of CVD Measure levels of risk factors Determine effect of diabetes on CVD Follow up to evaluate determinants of CVD Follow up to evaluate changes in risk factors
Rapid City
Strong Heart Study Population
4549 American Indians ages 45-74 years
NORTH DAKOTA
Arizona: Pima/Maricopa/Papago in the Gila River, Salt River, and Ak-Chin Indian communities Oklahoma: Apache, Caddo, Comanche, Delaware, Fort Sill Apache, Kiowa, and Wichita South/North Dakota: Oglala Sioux and Cheyenne River Sioux SD and the Spirit Lake Tribe in the Fort Totten area ND
ARIZONA
Spirit Lake Bismarck
Salt River Indian Community Phoenix Ak-Chin Ak-Chin
SOUTH DAKOTA
Rapid City Pine Ridge Cheyenne River Eagle Butte
Gila River Indian Community
Oglala
OKLAHOMA
Oklahoma City Anandarko Lawton
Strong Heart Study
1988-2003
Community Mortality
Study
3574-year-old men and women Deaths between 1984 and 1994 Medical record review of all possible CVD deaths
Physical Examinations of Cohort
1989-91, 1993-5 and 1998-9 ECG, Cardiac and Carotid ECHO Anthropometry, BP, ABI, PFT Blood, urine and DNA samples Medical and medication history Diet, PA, QOL, smoking, alcohol
Strong Heart Study
1988-2003
Cohort Surveillance
Yearly contact Medical record review for all cause and CVD Mortality and nonfatal CVD
Family Study
120 families of 30 members each Examination similar to that of cohort 10cM genetic map
Community Involvement
Study design and implementation American Indian investigators and staff Medical care to participants Data used for community health initiatives Education of community youth Participation in community health initiatives
The Strong Heart Study
Sgufk Ibthag Muschuma Oodham Natsu witu Pihi Comanche Tawahe Cante Suta Woospe Lakota
The Rising Tide of CVD
CVD and Total Mortality Rates
SD/ND vs Strong Heart Study, Men, 1986
per 10,000
600 500 400 300 200 100 0 S/ND SHS S/ND SHS S/ND SHS
CVD Mortality
Total Mortality
45-54 55-64 65-74
CVD and Total Mortality Rates
Arizona vs Strong Heart Study,
Men, 1986
per 10,000
600 500 400 300 200 100 0 AZ SHS AZ SHS AZ SHS
45-54 55-64 65-74
CVD Mortality
Total Mortality
CHD Incidence in American Indians
Compared to ARIC Population
Rate per 1000 person-years
CHD 45-64 years
ARIC SHS
20
10
Women
Men
CHD includes fatal and nonfatal events plus revascularization
Prevalence of Atherosclerotic Plaque in SHS and ARIC/CHS
Prevalence
100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 SHS ARIC/CHS
P001 P001 P001 P001 P001
45-49
50-54
55-59
60-64
65-69
70-74
75-79
79
Age years
Trends in CVD Mortality
The Strong Heart Study
/ 3 years
80
Women
60 40 20 0
Arizona Oklahoma Dakota Arizona
Men
Oklahoma
Dakota
1984-1986
1991-1993
Prevalence of Diabetes
Strong Heart Study, by Gender and Center
100 80
Women
Men
60
40 20 0 AZ OK ND/SD
Diabetes
AZ
IGT
OK
ND/SD
CVD by Gender and Diabetic Status
Percent/82 year Follow up Number/1000 per year
Nondiabetic
Men
Women
170 85 235 208
21 10 30 25
Diabetic
Men Women
Contribution of Diabetes to CHD
Strong Heart Study
Women Hazard Ratio Prevalence PAR 63 60 76 Men 31 50 51
CVD rates in American Indians are now
higher than in the general US population The rates are increasing The
majority of CVD occurs in people with diabetes
Effect of Epidemic of Diabetes on Duration-Related Complications
Cumulative DM cases Prevalence of complications among those with DM with DM15-year duration
450 No of Cases
50 40
300
Percent
30 20 10
150
0 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
Time years
0
16 new cases/yr Death occurs after 30-year DM; Complication incidence 50 after 15-year DM
Change in US CHD Death Rate
1950-2010 projection
Change
20
0
-20
-40
CHD
-60
1950 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
NIH, NHLBI Morbidity Mortality 1996 Chartbook on Cardiovascular, Lung, and Blood Diseases, USDHHS, 1996
Conventional Risk Factors New Risk Factors
CVD Risk Factors
HR
Age yr Gender Smoke SBP 10mm LDL 30mg HDL 5mg
104 p 00001 213 p 00001 139 p 001 112 p 00001 112 p 001 094 p 001 102 p 00001 112 p 015 134 p 001 118 p 00001 124 p 00001 092 p 0001
10
125
150
10
125
150
No Diabetes 86- year follow up n 261
Diabetes 82- year follow up n 420
Distribution of LDL Cholesterol in American Indians
LDL Cholesterol mg/dl
Distribution of Systolic Blood Pressure in Diabetic and Nondiabetic American Indians
Diabetic
Diabetic
Systolic blood pressure mmHg
d i a b e t Nondiabetic i c s
Systolic blood pressure mmHg
mm Hg
RR for Total Cholesterol in Framingham vs Strong Heart Study
Men FHS Ref 119 166 193 Men SHS Ref 163 231 287 Women Women FHS SHS Ref Ref 123 109 128 155 171 257
160-199 200-239 240-279 280
Implementation of Findings
Health Care Providers
Increased awareness of CVD because of SHS Development of Indian-specific Framingham predictive equation
Prevention Stop Atherosclerosis in Native Diabetics Study
3-year randomized intervention for LDL and BP usual targets LDL 75mg/dl, BP 115/75 endpoint carotid and coronary ECHO
Conventional Risk Factors New Risk Factors
Age- and Center-Adjusted Hazard Ratios for Albuminuria as Predictor of CVD
80 60 40 20 10
Women Men
Microalbuminuria
80 60 40 20 10
Women
Macroalbuminuria
Men
Albuminuria and LV Structure and Function
No Albuminuria N685 LV Mass gms LV Hypertrophy Fractional Shortening Ejection Fraction 155 36 a 23 a 35 6 a 64 8 a Micro-Alb N519 160 39 a 31 b 35 6 a 63 9 a Macro-Alb N372 181 50 b 49 c 33 8 b 60 12 b
Values with same superscript are not
significantly different
Prevalence of Abnormal
Diastolic Function Based on Albuminuria Status
40
P0008 P0001 NS
30 20
10
0
normal
micro
macro
Adjusted covariates: Age, gender, BMI, SBP, HgbA1C, coronary artery disease, ejection fraction, LV mass
Distribution of Fasting Insulin Levels
Strong Heart Study
IR and MS as Predictors of Diabetes
30
35
25
Percent
1st Tertile 2nd tertile Tertile of HOMA IR 3rd Tertile
30 Percent 25 20 15 10 5 0
20 15 10 5 0 Absent Present
ATP III Metabolic Syndrome
IR and MS as Predictors of CVD
10 9
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1st Tertile 2nd tertile Tertile of HOMA IR 3rd Tertile
8
Percent
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Absent Present
Percent
ATP III Metabolic Syndrome
The insulin resistance syndrome is not a strong determinant of CVD in non-diabetic American Indians Among the CVD risk factors and parameters of CV function, only lipoproteins and PAI-1 change significantly with increasing IR IR leads to diabetes before it leads to CVD
Inflammatory Markers?
Age- and Center-Adjusted Hazard Ratios for Fibrinogen as Predictor of CVD
80 60 40 20 10
Women Men
Elevated Fibrinogen and ECHO Abnormalities
OR adj ECHO
LVH Art Stiffness Low Contr
95 CI 110-173 111-188 070-157 122-187
138 145 105
151
Any of above
CRP - Population Comparisons
Study
SHS NHANES PRINCE CHS IRAS NHS MRFIT
Median/ Mean 38
Pop based Yes
Comments
Am Indian US 40 years US 21 years US AV 77 years Diabetes Women High-Risk Men
21 205 267 38 28 195
Yes Yes Yes No No No
CRP and CVD
Model RR for CRP 1 2 3 4 12 129 122 115 95 CI 105-138 112-149 105-140 099-135 Covariates none
gender, age, center, BMI, smoke, meds plus HT, DM, albuminuria plus PAI-1, fibrinogen
CRP high in populations with high rates of obesity and diabetes CRP, therefore, is a weaker predictor of CVD Fibrinogens stronger predictive value may reflect its relation to thrombosis as well as inflammation
Adiponectin ACRP30/ adipoQ
Produced by adipocytes, but plasma levels lower in obesity Sequence homologies to collagen and complement factor C1q Metabolic actions - related to increased insulin sensitivity Relations to inflammation Structural homologies to TNF
Inhibits NF-B signaling
Adiponectin as Predictor of CHD:
Multivariate Analysis
Model 1 Model 2 Model 3
Waist, age, FAT , SBP, albuminuria
HDL, LDL QUICKI
0
025
05
075
1
125
15
175
Odds Ratio CHD [95 CI]
Adiponectin as a Predictor of CHD:
Subgroups Model
2
Male DM Male No DM Female DM Female No DM
0
025
05
075
1
125
15
175
Odds Ratio CHD [95CI]
Adiponectin is: Related to BMI -, fasting insulin -, HDL Protective against later rises in fasting BG Positively related to albumin excretion
Markers of Pre-Clinical Disease?
Abnormalities of Cardiac Structure and Function in Diabetic and Non-Diabetic SHS Participants Without Known Coronary Disease
30
All p0001
Prevalence
25 20 15 10 5 0
LVH Low Contr Abnl Filling
Diabetes Non-DM
Relation of LV Mass/Height27 to Subsequent CVD and Non-CVD Mortality
3 25 2 15 1 05 0 Non-CVD Death CVD Death
p 001
Proportion dead
Normal LV Mass LV Hypertrophy
Adjusted for covariates
LV Function and CVD Mortality in Diabetes
100
11
98
Cumulative Survival
Cumulative Survival
10
96
94
EF
92
9
40 40-54
E/A15
No
90 0
55
10 20 30 40 50
8 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Yes
Months
Time months
LVEF
Abnormal LV Filling
Univariate Relative Risk of Mortality in Diabetes
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
207
p0001
954
ST Depression PCA Ratio QTc
Relative Risk
p0001 p0001
317 p0018 468
p0001 p00004
211 195
Cardiovascular Mortality
All-Cause Mortality
Multivariate Relative Risk of
Mortality in Diabetes
40 35 30
p00009
368
p0006
261
ST Depression PCA Ratio QTc
p0002 p0001 p0242
133 203
Relative Risk
25 20 15 10 05
p0082
187
236
00 Cardiovascular Mortality
All-Cause Mortality
Adjusted for age, sex, BMI, BP, HDL, LDL, TGs, albuminuria, alcohol use, smoking, prevalent CHD, and center
Application to the Clinical ECG
50 uV of ST depression 1/2 mm half
a small box The QTc is the longest interval from onset of QRS to the end of the T-wave PCA cannot be measured from ECG alone
Strong Heart Family Study
Phenotypes include ECG/BP, ECHOs, lipid and thrombotic markers, and glucose tolerance Covariates include demographic factors, lifestyle, reproductive history, and medical history
Numbers of Examined Relative Pairs
Strong Heart Family Study
Relationship
Parent-offspring Siblings Half-siblings Avuncular Grandparent-grandchild Grand avuncular First cousins First cousins once removed Second cousins Other Total Relative Pairs DA N326 336 330 86 954 129 395 1142 1091 487 621 5571 OK N310 245 319 77 802 35 139 843 409 57 322 3248 AZ N345 319 350 44 721 12 261 866 909 233 145 3975 SHFS N 981 900 999 207 2477 291 795 2851 2409 777 1088 12794
Heritabilities
for CVD Risk Factors
Strong Heart Family Study
Phenotype Proportion of Variance Due to Genes SE
44 54 39 50 40 23 29 44 23 007 007 006 007 007 006 008 008 006
BMI WHR LDL-C HDL-C lnTG SBP F Glu ln Ins ln Fibrinogen
Heritability h2 of LV Mass and Geometry in SHS-FS
045 04 035
Heritability
03 025 02 015 01 005 0
LV Mass LVIDd RWTd Overall Center
Heritability for QTL needed for power 80 in SHS
Genotype by Diabetes Status Interaction for CVD Risk Factors
Trait BMI Fat WHR HDL-C TG g, D 523 81 559 69 041 07 897 134 373 94 g, ND 581 55 614 57 058 06 390 48 g D, ND 34 p0002 52 p0005 69 p0353 02 p0096
924 108 62 p0307
Genetic and Environmental Correlations Between Diabetes and CVD Risk Factors
Risk Factor BMI Fat WHR HDL-C TG Fibrinogen PAI 1 SBP Genetic Environmental 55 14 10 13 38 14 11 14 58 15 13 14 -37 27 -32 18 65 21 33 13 40 17 20 11 67 17 18 10 57 21 11 11
SUMMARY
There is a rising tide of CVD in diabetes
LDL and blood pressure are strong risk factors Albuminuria, fibrinogen and ECHO/ECG abnormalities are also strong risk factors
Current strategy for prevention
Aggressive control of LDL and BP
SUMMARY, cont
Future directions for understanding the impact of
diabetes on CVD
Understand mechanism of cardiac abnormalities Explore further the inflammatory/thrombotic axis Study adipocyte mediators
Future direction - Genetics
Localize and identify genes contributing to CVD risk and measure their effects Identify genes that modulate therapeutic responses
The Strong Heart Study Investigators
Lyle Best, MD Linda Cowan, PhD Richard Devereux, MD Richard Fabsitz, PhD Jeffrey Henderson, MD WmJames Howard, MD Elisa Lee, PhD Albert Lewis Robert Lindsay, MD Kari North, PhD Jean MacCluer, PhD Peter Okin, MD Vittorio Palmieri, MD Helaine Resnick, PhD Everett Rhoades, MD David C Robbins, MD Giacomo Ruotolo, MD, PhD Thomas Welty, MD Jeunliang L Yeh, PhD Ellie Zephier, RD
The Strong Heart Study Field Staff
Marcia OLeary, BSN Lillian Brown Cherie Kessler Wendy Lawrence Francine Red Willow Taqueer Ali, PhD Linda Poolaw Karen Kimberly Stephanie Gomez Betty Jarvis, BSN Bert Lewis Rosinna Briones Mary Rybka Nanette Oram
Source:diabeteseducationandresearchcenter.org